Mouse within our house??? we have mice contained by our attic!!! we don't want to use...

we have mice contained by our attic!!! we don't want to use poison or get an exterminator. what should we do?? at first when we be using the traps, they would always win caught, but now they newly seem to be intake the peanut butter off of them and not catch caught!!! what can we do? is there a guaranteed kind of trap we should use??? do they get a lot of disease? what mode of diseases??? any information is greatly apreciated!!!
Answers:    Where's that Pied Piper when you need him?????????????........
Get a dutiful cat